When Your Manager Actually Knows: What a New Study Found About Telling the Truth at Work
One study looked at what can happen when an employee and manager have a supported conversation about mental health, and what it can’t tell us about whether opening up at work is right for you.
A familiar picture, not a case study of a real client
A Georgia commuter sits in her parked car on a lunch break, or in the quiet corner of a break room, phone in hand. She types a message to her manager, deletes it, and starts again. She can’t work out how much to say, or what might happen after she sends it.
In a small team where everyone is stretched, even a well-meaning, busy manager can be hard to approach. The question isn’t simply Should I tell them? It’s What do I want them to know, and what feels safe to share?
One recent UK study explored a structured way to support that conversation. It offers an interesting possibility, not an instruction to disclose.
What the study actually tested
Prudenzi and colleagues’ 2026 MENTOR 2.0 study was a feasibility pilot: a single-arm study with no control group, using repeated self-report surveys at baseline, mid-intervention, and after the programme. In plain language, it tested whether the programme could be delivered and whether participants found it acceptable. It was not a trial of whether the programme works.
The team recruited 24 employee-manager pairs. One employee participated without their manager, leaving 23 employees and 19 managers; four managers supported two employees each. Everyone came from one hospitality employer in the Midlands region of the UK.
Taking part did not require a formal mental health diagnosis. The authors viewed that requirement as a possible barrier and a source of stigma, and wanted to make room for early support.
On feasibility, the results were encouraging. Of 108 sessions, 94% (102) ran on the originally scheduled date and time, 91% lasted at least the intended 50 minutes, the five sessions took an average of 65 days to complete, and 87% of participants were still in the study at the end. Three employees withdrew after the baseline, mostly because of competing responsibilities and limited capacity.
The online programme ran over about nine weeks and included five sessions with a trained Mental Health Employment Liaison Worker: four with the employee alone and one joint session with the manager in the room. It was a role created to hold the conversation between the two of them. Sessions covered values and goals, difficult situations at work, open conversations about mental health, joint action planning, and how to keep things going afterwards. Managers had a 30-minute introduction, optional preparation and follow-up meetings, and the one joint session.
Grounded in contextual behavioural science, the programme focused on psychological flexibility and values-based action, not diagnosis. It was designed for people already working, to help them stay well and stay employed, not to get them into work. The University of Birmingham team worked with Mind and Burton and District Mind; the study was funded by Midlands Engine and the University of Birmingham.
Why a third person in the room mattered so much
For some participants, the liaison worker’s independence from the employer made it easier to speak. Several said they valued having a neutral third party who was not part of the company. As one participant put it: “I didn’t have to worry about impacting working relationships as they were completely unrelated to the company.”
That detail matters. A manager may be supportive, but is still part of the workplace hierarchy. A liaison worker could provide a separate, designated space to prepare, reflect, and decide what to bring into the joint meeting.
The programme was a UK workplace intervention delivered by a mental health charity. It was not therapy, and a therapist is not the same as a liaison worker. Managers are not therapists either, and should not be expected to take on that role.

The numbers that moved
Employees’ self-reported distress was measured with the 12-item General Health Questionnaire (GHQ-12), scored from 0 to 36, with higher scores indicating more distress. The group average went from 15.78 at baseline, classified by the paper as symptomatic, to 9.09 midway and 6.35 at the end, classified as asymptomatic. The change over time was statistically significant: F(2, 44) = 27.80, p = .001.
The study also found statistically significant within-group changes in self-rated productivity, work engagement (13.44 to 14.80), psychological flexibility on the valued-action subscale (33.39 to 40.06), and workplace interpersonal relationships (38.96 to 42.27).
These are changes observed in one group over time. Without a comparison group, they do not show the programme caused them. Work conditions might have changed; simply having time to be listened to might have mattered; other factors could have played a part. The authors themselves caution against treating these preliminary findings as proof. One detail I found quietly hopeful: in the authors' exploratory analyses, whether or not someone arrived with a formal diagnosis did not appear to change the picture, which hints that this kind of support may be useful whether or not someone has a label for what they are carrying. Treat that as a hint, not a finding, given the sample size.
The number that did not move
Here’s the most revealing contrast. Employees rated the quality of their relationship with their manager on a single seven-point question. Their average rose from 5.8 to 5.91 and then 6.06, but that change was not statistically significant: F(1.49, 32.68) = 1.80, p = .178.
Managers’ ratings of the same relationship, using the seven-item Leader-Member Exchange scale, rose from 26.00 to 27.97. A statistically significant change, p = .001. And 91% of managers who gave feedback said they noticed a positive change in their employee.
One manager who did not see a change said, in effect, that they understood the employee better now, so the change was more on their side.
That is not a failure of the conversation. It is a reminder that two people can experience the same meeting differently. Managers may notice a shift in understanding before employees see a meaningful change in behaviour. A handful of joint sessions may not rewrite a workplace hierarchy, or address what an employee is still waiting to see.
What people said it gave them
Participants described feeling “really listened to” and valued having a designated time to reflect and “take a step back.” Some said they found it easier to be open and honest with their boss and team. Others described becoming less self-critical: learning to stop being so hard on themselves and to believe they were “good enough.”
They also raised practical frustrations: the 22 research surveys per participant felt tedious, and some found the workbooks hard to use alone. Those complaints were about study paperwork, not the sessions. Several participants wanted follow-up sessions to help keep things going.

What this study cannot tell you
The limits are important:
It had one arm and no control group. It cannot show that the programme caused change or compare it with another approach.
The sample was small: 23 employees and 19 managers from one hospitality employer in one UK region.
Among those who completed demographics, participants were mostly White British and mostly female. Six of 23 employees did not complete the demographic questionnaire at all.
All outcomes were self-reported, including productivity, which was measured with a single self-rated item and is open to bias.
There was no follow-up assessment, so we don’t know whether any changes lasted beyond the last session.
The GHQ-12 is a screening questionnaire, not a diagnosis; the study did not include clinical interviews.
Employees answered a single, ad hoc relationship question, while managers used a validated seven-item scale. Those measures are not directly comparable.
The study compared nothing. It cannot tell us whether a joint session is better than a usual one-to-one conversation, or better than no programme.
These results are not estimates for Georgia, the United States, the hospitality industry as a whole, or any individual reader.
And disclosure at work is not safe for everyone. Some workplaces punish it. Choosing not to tell your employer is a legitimate decision, not a failure of openness.
What may help right now
You do not have to make one big disclosure. You can consider what feels useful and safe, one step at a time:
Decide separately what your manager needs to know, what HR needs to know, and what stays yours.
Ask for a specific change if that’s what would help. “I need meetings to start at nine so I can get my kid to school” may be easier to act on than sharing a diagnosis.
Write the hardest sentence first if saying it out loud feels like too much.
Pick your moment, not the worst moment of your week.
Bring someone with you to a formal meeting if having support or a record matters to you.
Notice when strain reaches your sleep, appetite, or work, or when low mood lasts two weeks. Treat that as information worth responding to.
Keep one relationship at work that isn’t your manager’s.
Let a therapist help you rehearse the conversation you keep deleting.
When it may help to talk
If your distress is affecting daily life or you want support sorting through your options, speaking with a mental health professional may help you decide what fits. You deserve a safe, supportive, and respectful space to explore your choices without pressure to disclose at work. If you or someone else is in immediate danger, call 911; for the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline, call or text 988.
A gentle next step
At Talk to Heal Counseling Center, I work with adults, couples, and families using a contemporary, collaborative approach to therapy. We offer therapy in many different languages and accept insurance including UHC, Aetna, Cigna, and many others.
Call 404-369-3838
Care is provided only in the State of Georgia. For online sessions, you must be physically located in Georgia at the time of your session.

You are allowed to be a person at work
You can seek support without deciding today what to tell your manager. If therapy feels like a helpful place to begin, book a free 15-minute consultation or schedule online. I offer therapy in many different languages and accept UHC, Aetna, Cigna, and many other insurance plans. Call 404-369-3838. Care is only available in Georgia; online clients must be physically in Georgia during sessions.
Prudenzi A, Hastings O, Grey L, Johnston N, Stuart J, Marwaha S. “Feasibility and acceptability of a joint employee-manager workplace intervention to support mental health and job retention (MENTOR 2.0).” BMC Public Health. 2026;26:2951. Published 18 July 2026. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-025-24457-7
This was a small feasibility study with no control group. Its findings cannot establish that the programme caused the changes observed.

Comments